No, I’m not talking about those ubiquitous Amazon delivery trucks dominating the city roads. I’m talking about this discovery:
Researchers have detected a cluster of lost 2,500-year-old cities at the foothills of the Andes in the Amazon rainforest.
This amazing discovery, the oldest and largest of its kind in the region, includes a vast system of farmland and roads, revealing that Ecuador’s Upano Valley was densely populated from about 500 BCE to between 300 and 600 CE.
Led by French National Center for Scientific Research archaeologist Stéphen Rostain, a multi-national team analyzed data from more than two decades of interdisciplinary research in the region, recently expanded by light detection and ranging (LIDAR) mapping.
Covering an area of 300-square-kilometers (115-square-miles), LIDAR mapped platforms, plazas, and streets arranged in a geometric pattern, interwoven with agricultural drainage, terraces, and incredibly long, straight roads that connected a number of urban sites. …
The organization of the cities reveals the sophistication and engineering capabilities of these ancient cultures, according to the researchers, who concluded that the ‘garden urbanism’ of the Upano Valley provides further proof that Amazonia is not the pristine forest once depicted.
There is a lot more information at the link, including diagrams. These sorts of new techniques for discovery are not limited to the Amazon – they are revolutionizing archaeology in many areas, as well as physical anthropology.
One of the particularly horrible things about the aftermath of October 7 and the Israeli reaction to it is that the Hamas/Palestinian sympathizers are both ignorant of history and don’t even attempt to make logical arguments. Or perhaps they’re not so ignorant and they are lying. But again, they don’t even try logic; just slogans and Orwellian reversals.
Of course that isn’t just the hallmark of the talk around this particular issue. We see it over and over from the left, and although it’s not limited to the left it’s extremely prevalent there; it’s the left’s meat and potatoes, as it were. It shouldn’t persuade anyone but it certainly does, because it is vehement and “passionate,” and appeals to emotion which is a strong element in the way most human beings make their decisions and decide on their allegiances. And it thrives on historical ignorance and lazy thinking, which are usually in abundant supply.
I was talking to a friend recently about the Israel/Palestine question, mentioning some facts she hadn’t previously realized, and she said to me: “If what you say is true, then Israel is really really bad at PR.” Good point. I answered that, although PR is not their strong suit, when they do mount good arguments and inform people of history – which they have done over and over again – people deflect it with lies and hatred, and pretty much shout them down with slogans. And when the entire MSM and much of the world is arrayed against you, it’s very hard to make yourself heard in a way that counts.
Which brings me to this statement from Naftali Bennett, with which I happen to agree:
What is it about the Gaza war that’s causing all these riots around the world?
During the past 50 years the world has seen HUNDREDS of terrible wars. None of them caused the massive anti-Israel riots we’re seeing now in the universities.
So what’s unique about this particular…
— Naftali Bennett ????? ??? (@naftalibennett) May 2, 2024
If for some reason you can’t read the whole tweet, here’s the gist of the rest of it:
Are there more civilian losses in Gaza (10,000-14,000) than in other wars? Not at all. The war in Congo killed MILLIONS. The Syrian civil war almost a million. The wars in Iraq and Afghanistan killed hundreds of thousands each.
Was it that Israel initiated this war? Nope. This war started ONLY because of the savage October 7th massacre that Hamas executed against innocent babies, women and men.
So why? What’s is it about this war that gets these intellectuals and students out there burning and breaking into buildings?
Why is the ICC singling out Israel?
You know the answer: Because it’s Israel, the only Jewish State on earth. It’s the Jews.
It’s the same reason Jews were singled out for the past 2000 years. Jews were accused of being lazy or too ambitious;
of behaving differently or trying to assimilate; of being weaklings or being too strong; of being an economic burden on society or succeeding too much in business. The true reason was none of these. It was because they were Jews. This wave of Israel-hate is simply a new incarnation of good old antisemitism.
The double standard is the tell: Jews are treated differently than every other people on earth.
On “X,” in response to Bennett’s tweet, you can see a torrent of bile that ignores what he is actually saying and employs the usual Orwellian slogans. It’s as though, if words are repeated often enough, they become true. And in fact that’s the way it works in many people’s minds and perceptions.
For example, the very first response I see there is this: “The GENOCIDE… Are you ret*rded?” Not an argument at all, nor does it answer any of Bennett’s arguments. It’s merely the ploy of repeating the world “genocide” – this time in all-caps – as though Israel’s commission of genocide (which is easy to refute in factual and logical terms) is so screamingly self-evident that to deny it is to be a “retard.”
The next response is a recitation of how the Palestinians are the poor suffering victims of Israel. Palestinians are certainly victims – of Hamas (whom they elected, so the victimhood is of their own volition), and earlier on of other Arab nations. But the only reason Israel ever wars on them is because the Palestinians have been perpetrators of violence against Israel from the very start. And the reason the Palestinians’ Arab neighbors have become somewhat cool towards giving them refuge is that they’ve wreaked havoc and chaos on every Arab nation they’ve entered as well, trying to overthrow governments and foment civil war.
The next tweet: “The murderer is asking why me and not all the other murderers.” It’s not murder to kill in a defensive war, which is what Israel is reluctantly doing. If the Palestinians stopped attacking Israelis there would be no war. But that distinction is utterly lost. Let’s say for the sake of argument, however, that Israel really is murdering a certain number of Palestinians, in which case it would certainly be valid to compare degrees of murder in terms of numbers lost in wars.
In the next tweet we hear from a holdout on the Israeli left: “Your arrogance, hatred and racism. That’s what. And I’m speaking as an Israeli-born Jew.” I don’t see anything Bennett has said there that exhibits hatred or racism. But name-calling is the way it goes, when you can’t out-argue someone, and “racist” is always good for the purpose.
The next two tweets are of the “GENOCIDE!” variety. And then some of the pro-Israel tweets begin. But it’s the nature of the anti-Israel ones that proves Bennett’s point, although their authors certainly don’t think so.
I’ll end by quoting one of the pro-Israel tweets. Here’s an excerpt:
What’s happening around the world has nothing to do with Gaza or how Israel is. It has everything to do with pure Jew hatred by the Arabs towards the Jews. And the young people protesting against Israel are so uneducated, brainwashed and stupid that they believe the lies. They’re like idiotic flies flying into a Venus flytrap and believing the Venus flytrap when it tells the fly that it is the victim and is there for peace. Then boom!!!
The Jews have been trying to tell these idiots what’s coming. We’ve had 1400 years of being the flies and we know now what the Venus flytrap is and will do. Yet these imbeciles see their enemy as their friends just before they too get eaten alive.
Why are they so stupid?
Because it’s pure Jew hatred. They fight for the rights of the minority, yet march hand in hand with 24% of the human population against 0.1%. They’re fighting against the very cause they claim to be protesting for.
Why? Because they’re indoctrinated like simpletons by pure Jew haters.
Speaking of indoctrination, last night I listened to a good interview with Coleman Hughes. In it, he describes (among other things) the extent of the pro-Palestinian propaganda he saw back when he was a Columbia student in 2015-2020. I’ve cued it up for that section, which lasts about four minutes (by the way, the interviewer seems to be Bret Stephens, who is generally awful on anything related to Trump but has been pretty good on Israel):
And here’s the entire interview; well worth watching:
UNC wasn’t the only school where the frat community rose to [Israel’s] defense—at Arizona State, frat boys helped the police dismantle a pro-Hamas encampment, ushering in calls to “bring back the frats” and online celebrations of Greek life as “one of the few remaining bulwarks of sanity on campus.”
But there’s a certain irony in the outpouring of appreciation for the bros. Especially at elite schools where the encampments have been most persistent, fraternities have faced university-driven witch hunts aimed at eliminating their presence on campuses. The anti-frat crusade, which features a questionable judicial process led by antagonistic university bureaucrats hired to promote DEI initiatives, is troubling enough before you consider its glaring hypocrisy in the face of the ongoing protests. Universities that now treat the smallest fraternity infractions as grounds for immediate and sometimes harsh limitation—including accidentally setting off smoke alarms with a candle to turning in party permit applications an hour late—are now, very publicly, allowing disruptive and even aggressive encampments to persist despite their deliberate violations of policy, making the school’s double standards for the application of rules and the distribution of consequences abundantly clear.
Other things come to mind, as well: the fake Rolling Stonerape story, the fake Duke rape story before that, and the words of CEO Alissa Gordon Heinerscheid about Bud Light’s advertising no longer appealing to a “frat boy” image.
The Tablet article describes how Cornell polices fraternities, compared to – well, you’ll see [my emphasis]:
At Cornell, the school uses an anonymous reporting system in which anyone can submit a complaint against a frat, even people who don’t attend the university—which can then become near-immediate grounds for a formal investigation during which the fraternity may very likely be suspended. This happened as recently as February, when Cornell’s Office of Student Conduct and Community Standards (OSCCS) received “an anonymous incident report” making unspecified allegations against at least 10 fraternities. By 9 p.m. the same day, OSCCS emailed every new member of those fraternities encouraging them to come forward with their own reports; three days later the school began suspending the accused chapters. The frats were prohibited from all social activity during the investigation, which included banning new members from eating at the house, even though they were paying for the fraternity meal plan, and limiting events at campus apartments occupied by graduating seniors, some of whom even had to cancel their birthday parties. I talked to one senior who wrote to the university, explaining that their guidelines were making it impossible to hold even small gatherings among friends and asking for additional clarity so seniors could find approved ways to enjoy their final days as students—especially since the anti-Israel protests were making campus life notably unenjoyable.
“It was frustrating because most people in our frat are Jewish, and the frat really was essential for us while there were swastikas being drawn on school sidewalks and people were yelling ‘From the river to the sea’ every day,” he said. “I said in my email to the school that campus is divided, isolating, and even threatening for Jews sometimes, so having the fraternity social network is actually a critical part of our lives. They didn’t even respond to my message.” The school lifted his frat’s suspension nearly a month later after the university found insufficient evidence for the allegations.
This incident—and the myriad other times the school leaped to penalize even unsubstantiated infractions—is still fresh in the minds of Cornell fraternity brothers as they watch the university’s noisy Gaza encampment enter its second week, despite multiple statements from the school pointing out its many rule violations. “It’s pretty clear the school views a certain type of rule break as honorable and just, and other rule breaks as violations by entitled jerks, so this was not surprising to me,” the senior said.
“All animals are equal, but some are more equal than others,” wrote Orwell, a keen observer of the left.
Much more at the link.
Perhaps it would help if fraternities renamed themselves “fraternités” in honor of the slogan of the leftist French revolution.
You may find his voice grating. To me, he’s no Barry Gibb, but I’ve always very much liked The Four Seasons and they provided a major part of the soundtrack to my youth. I find it difficult to pick a favorite Four Seasons song, but this one comes to mind, although the choice is somewhat arbitrary:
There are a bunch of quite recent videos of Valli singing, but looking at a few I suspect they might be lip-synced. Oh, well, the guy is 90, so I’ll forgive him. Happy Birthday, Frankie!
And speaking of Barry Gibb, I can’t resist mentioning the song that is the intersection between the two men, because Gibb wrote it for Valli:
Jim Jacobs and Warren Casey had written a different title track for Grease for its original Chicago production, but the song was discarded when the show was picked up on Broadway. Barry Gibb was commissioned to compose a new title song for Robert Stigwood’s film of the stage musical.
… Gibb invited … Peter Frampton to play guitar on the Grease session, while also providing backing vocals himself. … Frankie Valli was approached to provide the vocals, due to his vocal range being similar to that of Barry Gibb, his being under the management of Allan Carr at the time, and his status as a popular singer from the pre-British Invasion era that Grease represented. Gibb had a long-standing respect for Valli as “one of the hallmark voices of our generation”. … When Valli recorded “Grease”, he did not have a recording contract, having been contracted to Private Stock Records which had folded earlier in 1978. After the single was released on the RSO label, which also issued the soundtrack, Valli quickly landed a deal with Warner Bros., which had Valli’s group The Four Seasons under contract at the time. …
“Grease” became a number-one single in the United States in 1978 and also reached number forty on the R&B charts in the same year. Later in 1978, Valli released a follow-up album, the title of which, Frankie Valli… Is the Word, echoes the “grease is the word” lyric contained in the chorus of “Grease”. “Grease” was Valli’s final Top 40 hit.
“Grease” never was a big favorite of mine, but Barry Gibb was a hit machine, and he certainly did right by Valli.
NOTE: I see from that Wiki entry that backing vocals on “Grease” were also provided by The Sweet Inspirations, a group I liked at the time and many of whose members were related to Dionne Warwick (an early member) and Whitney Houston. Another family loaded with musical talent.
I have to say, Trump knows how to make lemonade out of those lemons he’s been handed. The latest:
Donald Trump dropped by a New York Fire Department station in midtown Manhattan Thursday to deliver pizzas after spending another day in court for DA Alvin Bragg’s case against the former president for falsifying business records.
The firefighters appeared to be pleased to see him, and in the video you can hear one or more say, “Save us, please save us.”
Trump was born and raised in New York and is really a New Yorker at heart. Although certain people in the city have turned on him, using the court system, and although the city’s voters are overwhelmingly blue, he’s not giving up on his hometown:
At the fire station, Trump reiterated his “love” for New York City.
“We’re going to come in. Number one, you have to stop crime, and we’re going to let the police do their job. They have to be given back their authority. They have to be able to do their job,” Trump said. “And we’re going to come into New York. We’re making a big play for New York, other cities too. But this city, I love this city.”
I don’t think Trump has a chance to take New York City. But I like his spirit. More importantly, can he take the swing states? Polls indicate the answer might be “yes,” but that would depend on voter turnout and the amount of “rigging” that goes on.
Hanson is always worth listening to, and this is no exception. I’m often struck by how well he sums up a situation and adds his own unique observations. This is long, but Hanson isn’t long-winded. He has a great deal to say that’s of substance. I would love to have taken a course from him in college.
If you’re pressed for time, though, watch however much you can. It also helps to click on “settings” and speed it up; I usually listen to talking-head videos that way:
Over thirty years ago, Allan Bloom used the phrase “dancing bears” to describe the capitulation of university professors to student threats of violence and the occupation of buildings. His original quote from The Closing of the American Mind involved the student uprising at Cornell in 1969:
Students discovered that pompous teachers who catechized them about academic freedom could, with a little shove, be made into dancing bears.
For a while now, however, universities have been so dominated by the left and unanimity of leftist thought that I doubt many professors catechize about academic freedom, except for their own. Students have been taught that the right has no say in the matter and that it’s all about power anyway. Therefore students – and a hefty number of “outside agitators” – probably are not the least bit surprised that their college administrators have turned into the most tractable of dancing bears.
Here’s what went on at Rutgers. Its aptly-named President Holloway gave in to the pro-Gazan demonstrators’ demands, which included: to consider divestment from Israel, to give ten “displaced Palestinian students” scholarships, to plan an Arab Cultural Center, to consider exchanges and study abroads with Birzeit University (in the West Bank), to form a Middle East Studies department (it surprises me that they don’t already have one; I assume that they already have courses in these subjects, however), to display flags of “occupied people” (does Rutgers have a flag? It could be included), amnesty for the demonstrators, and the following:
Rutgers–New Brunswick will work to develop training sessions on anti-Palestinian, antiArab, and anti-Muslim racism for all RU administrators & staff. We also commit to the hiring of a senior administrator who has cultural competency in and with Arab, Muslim, and Palestinian communities in the Division of Diversity, Inclusion, and Community.
In other words, Arabs and Palestinians will have pride of place in the school’s almost certainly already-robust DEI culture.
When Rutgers decides to dhimmi up, it doesn’t mess around.
Intrigued by the name of Rutgers’ president – which made me think of T. S. Eliot’s Hollow Men – I looked Holloway up. His story is an interesting one. He is Rutgers’ first black president, taking office in January of 2020. Here is some of his history:
Holloway was appointed Master (now known as “Head”) of Calhoun College (now known as Grace Hopper College) in 2005, and chaired the governing body of Yale’s residential colleges, the Council of Masters, from 2009 to 2014. As a Master, Holloway was respected for his approachability, charisma, and involvement in student life. For several years, he opposed the change of name of Calhoun, despite student demands, and noted the irony of his serving as the Master of that college; but he changed his mind as many students became more vocal in their opposition to the name in 2015.
So he caved on that.
More:
During the protests regarding Halloween costumes at Yale in November 2015, while he was dean, Holloway strongly supported the costume guidelines issued by his office (guidelines which some critics saw as unnecessary), calling them “exactly right.” Holloway is a supporter of affirmative action programs and reparations (albeit not cash transfers).
So, very “woke.”
More:
Holloway left Yale and became provost of Northwestern University on August 1, 2017.
So he was at Northwestern, too. Interesting, but perhaps just a coincidence.
I think, however, it’s not really about Holloway. The entire academic system is rotten through and through, and the rot goes way back and is hardly limited to black administrators, or female ones, or any particular demographic except woke and leftist.
I’ll close with the last lines of Eliot’s poem “The Hollow Men” – a poem I first encountered when I was about twelve and was much taken with:
This is the way the world ends
This is the way the world ends
This is the way the world ends
Not with a bang but a whimper.
NOTE: My post about Northwestern can be found here.
Those 45 cities where the receiving international airports are finally came to official light via the House Homeland Security Committee …
The administration’s tightly guarded city airport locations confirm a Center for Immigration Studies report published on April 1, 2024, which disclosed that Florida airports by far led all other states in flight landings of 326,000 immigrants through March, distantly followed in still significant numbers by Texas, New York, and California. …
The new data also confirms prior Center reports that about 43 U.S. airports were taking in immigrants from international flights. …
“It is a secret because . . . they don’t tell us anytime somebody comes in,” DeSantis complained during an April 4 press conference when asked about the Center’s report of a few days earlier. “They don’t give us any information on it. They are not coordinating with state government at all. If they throw six people on a commercial flight coming from a foreign country, there’s no acknowledgement at all to state or local authorities. That’s just a fact.” …
Begun in October 2022 for Venezuelans and expanded in January 2023 to Cubans, Haitians, Nicaraguans, and Colombians, the program approves flight travel authorizations for aspiring illegal border-crossers still in other countries to instead arrange commercial airline passage for themselves over the southern border and then receive temporary but easily renewable “humanitarian parole” from CBP officers at the airport, with immediate eligibility for renewable work permits. The rationale for the program is to “reduce the number of individuals crossing unlawfully” over the southern border — by flying them over it directly into the interior and then releasing them on parole.
I wonder what the ratio of Venezuelans and Cubans is to other groups, because it occurs to me that Venezuelans and Cubans fleeing their leftist governments would be likely to vote for the political right rather than the left.
The other day I wrote about Northwestern University’s craven capitulation to its hate-filled pro-Hamas pro-Palestine anti-Israel anti-Jewish demonstrators.
So I’m very much in favor of this move by the Equal Protection Project:
On April 29, 2024, Northwestern University struck a deal to have the pro-Hamas unauthorized encampment removed, with a twist not seen at other universities. Northwestern agreed to establish preferences for “Palestinian” students in accessing a new scholarship program and “MENA/Muslim” [MENA = Middle East North Africa] students in housing.
These ethnic, national origin, and shared ancestry preferences violate Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.
On May 1, the Equal Protection Project (EqualProtect.org) filed a Civil Rights Complaint [full embed can be found at the bottom of the linked post) with the Office for Civil Rights of the U.S. Department of Education. OCR has jurisdiction because Northwestern receives federal funding.
Specifically:
In violation of Title VI, the stated commitment of the University to provide five scholarships exclusively to “Palestinian” students illegally excludes and discriminates against non-Palestinian students based on their ethnicity, national origin, and shared ancestry. Additionally, the reservation of space and housing for “MENA/Muslim” students appears to be segregationist in nature, excluding at least in part students on the basis of ethnicity, national origin, and shared ancestry.
You can find out more about the Equal Protection Project at this link. You can donate there as well; it’s a worthy cause.
Last night, CNN spent its prime time segment decrying the Democratic president’s “radio silence” on the Gaza-related campus protests and chaos.
They must be realizing it doesn’t play well with the American public, and since they very much want Biden to win the election they want him to say something on the subject. And so he did:
"There is no place for hate speech or violence of any kind, whether its antisemitism, Islamophobia or discrimination against Arab Americans or Palestinian Americans. It's simply wrong," Pres. Biden says during remarks on campus protests. https://t.co/8o7HAK8j8xpic.twitter.com/Slq8PrStJo
The amazing thing, really, is that there isn’t more “Islamophobia” – which is not a phobia but is a reaction to the fact that a very significant number of Muslims (especially those in the Middle East) are in favor of enslaving the rest of the world, killing apostates, murdering homosexuals, raping and torturing and burning Israelis, and blowing Israelis and Westerners to bits. Little things like that.
And so now that Biden finally manages to say something about the horrendous hatred and violence unleashed against Jews, why is he generalizing about “hate” and why is he devoting so many words to “Islamophobia” and “discrimination against Arab Americans or Palestinian Americans”? It’s not the issue at all right now and never was, and in fact Biden’s statement is very much the sort of thing that Biden falsely accuses Trump of having said in Charlottesville about good people on both sides (Trump was actually talking about the statue issue and not the anti-black demonstrations).
We know why Biden – and/or his speechwriters – is saying this. He is terribly afraid that any time he says anything nice about Israelis or Jews, a huge number of Democrat voters don’t like it. Many of those voters are those very same “Arab Americans or Palestinian Americans” who live in the swing state of Michigan – and by the way, Palestinians are Arabs, so the phrase is needlessly redundant.