Home » It’s not easy being a spokesperson

Comments

It’s not easy being a spokesperson — 18 Comments

  1. ” And if the responses are lies, coverup, and/or spin, so much the more difficult, because it’s harder to keep a pack of lies straight than it is to tell the truth. ”

    I know what you’re saying, but I don’t think it’s quite right. If you’re memorizing a story and reciting it back, it doesn’t matter how true it is as long as it’s consistent. I mean, the press secretary doesn’t know how whether a country has complied with a treaty or a bill has been passed. It’s not like there are cover-ups that a press secretary has knowledge of. I could recite The Lord of the Rings or the Battle of Waterloo equally well if I had notes beforehand. That is in fact the reason I don’t listen to press conferences. A truth, a lie, or a typo all sound the same.

  2. Rudyard Kipling:
    The Female of the Species


    When the early Jesuit fathers preached to Hurons and Choctaws,
    They prayed to be delivered from the vengeance of the squaws.
    ‘Twas the women, not the warriors, turned those stark enthusiasts pale.
    For the female of the species is more deadly than the male…
    http://www.potw.org/archive/potw96.html

  3. It may not be easy as argued.
    However, there are those who make it appear so, and, who’ve done a damned fine job at it:

    Tony Snow, none were better.
    Dana Perino, professional and respectable

  4. I’m terribly biased, but I thought Tony Snow was an excellent spokesman. Never felt like he was snarking or serving up preposterous b.s. like I do with each of Obama’s spokesmen. He always seems of good cheer and interested in sharing what he could with a certain grace and humor.

    (Yeah, I’m definitely biased…)

  5. I remember many such from many regimes. Most, from what I recall… were functional or actual sociopaths. Actually, when you mentioned, I do recall Carney looking pained, on many an occasion, even as few times as I bothered to see what propaganda he was spewing. Looked like his shoes were too tight but he was trying to will them to be the right size. So, yes, I think he knew. Of course, I am not sure if that doesn’t actually make him worse. The others have no soul to sell, he seemed to but continued anyway. Who knows though. Maybe he has some medical or mental condition that puts him in some slight perpetual distress… when on his feet, or all the time, or some such. Still, I suspect as you do, he knew he was lying, and he knew why he was lying, and why was expected to lie. It didn’t seem to set well with him on some level.

  6. Lizzy:

    Well if you’re biased, then I’m biased too, because I agree that he was great.

    I very much liked Dana Perino as well.

  7. Josh Earnest is extremely adept at deflecting or dodging questions with a straight face. He’s way more talented at lying with a straight face than the other two. Ms.Harf is a distant third.

  8. Neo’s analysis is thorough and insightful as only she, experienced in psychotherapy, seems to have done. I watch a lot of Fox News and use my remote to speed to what interests me, and so have watched a lot of these conferences. And, I have regularly wonder how they do it – mental gymnastics, as well as emotionally – shame or pride in making the best of a difficult situation. These two women don’t look very confident or happy, but perhaps that see themselves as actresses playing difficult roles. And, I also paid careful attention to how GW Bush expressed himself poorly, even though I agreed with what he was trying to say. I too, thought that Dana Perino and Tony Snow were excellent and did not betray their integrity.

    I don’t agree with Nick. They can’t just memorize talking points; they have to try to be consistent with the contorted logic presented as press conferences go on.

  9. There’s an episode of Seinfeld where Jerry has to beat a lie-detector on whether or not he watches Melrose Place. He asks George how to do it.

    George says, “Remember, it’s not a lie if you believe it.”

    I think that kind of ability is necessary for the job.

  10. I think they consider they’ve got a fabulous job in the service of a wonderful president,…

    People like these who are willing to promulgate lies in service of someone they think is the bees’ knees are otherwise known as cult members.

  11. A society in which such people are need by the ten of thousand or millions is too depraved to know the truth.

  12. the litanny of things you brought up as to what they do, requires sociopathy… ie. no guilt… you find it hard because you have guilt, but if you did not have it, ie. your sociopathic, then what bothers you wont bother you.

  13. George says, “Remember, it’s not a lie if you believe it.”

    I thought if you crossed your fingers behind your back it’s not a lie.

  14. The current administration are sociopaths, all sociopaths up and down the line. Except for the homicidal megalomaniacs, who, if sufficiently intelligent, get the top jobs. Why we are not having treason trials, I cannot understand.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

HTML tags allowed in your comment: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>